5/24/2008

Writing Factory Girls

By Leslie T. Chang

I started writing my book on a March morning in 2006. About fifteen minutes into it, panic hit: I am no longer earning a salary just sitting here at my desk. By mid-morning, another realization had set in: I can’t go back to being a newspaper reporter.

The book, Factory Girls: From Village to City in a Changing China, opens inside the world of the young women working on assembly lines in the south China factory city of Dongguan:

When you met a girl from another factory, you quickly took her measure. “What year are you?” you asked each other, as if speaking not of human beings but of the makes of cars. “How much a month? Including room and board? How much for overtime?” Then you might ask what province she was from. You never asked her name.

To have a true friend inside the factory was not easy. Girls slept twelve to a room, and in the tight confines of the dorm it was better to keep your secrets. Some girls joined the factory with borrowed ID cards and never told anyone their real names. Some spoke only to those from their home provinces, but that had risks: Gossip traveled quickly from factory to village, and when you went home every auntie and granny would know how much you made and how much you saved and whether you went out with boys.

Almost everything is wrong with that opening, from a newspaper editor’s point of view. Who is speaking here? What is this story about? How do you know this? From the opening inside the factory, I move on to introduce a sixteen-year-old migrant worker named Lu Qingmin, tracing her arrival in Dongguan, her early job-hopping, and the overwhelming sense of isolation that is what most migrants remember from their first days in the city. Only ten pages into the book do I give some background: Today China has 130 million migrant workers…Together they represent the largest migration in human history, three times the number of people who immigrated to America from Europe over a century. But I have faith that the reader will stick with me—to be absorbed in the details of the factory world and a single young woman’s story before I stop to explain the broader context. Newspapers have no such faith: An editor would insist that these facts be up high. The reader must be told right away that this is a Very Important Story.

I hear the voice of this imaginary editor in my head all the time—I suspect that every newspaper reporter does. It is the voice that reminds you of all the rules you must follow in order to write an airtight story based on attributable facts. Journalism is a self-congratulatory profession; it likes to celebrate its courage in speaking truth to power and breaking taboos. What is almost never acknowledged is how rigid are its conventions when it comes to itself.

*

After graduating from college, I did a reporting internship at the Miami Herald and then worked at an expatriate newspaper in Prague. I joined the Wall Street Journal in 1993, first in Hong Kong, later moving to Taiwan and then China. I thought that newspapers offered the most writing opportunities to a young person. Only gradually did I realize that journalism is not writing, that its value lay elsewhere—particularly in explaining a place as complex and misunderstood as China. The Wall Street Journal, with its emphasis on long features that upset the conventional wisdom, suited me. Not every newspaper would run a series presenting grinding factory work as a path to upward mobility—as my bureau chief put it, “the happy face of exploitative capitalism.” I liked and respected my fellow reporters, and my editors as well. My quarrel has never been with them, but with the inflexible rules of the trade that they were called upon to enforce.

As I began writing my book, I realized I would have to unlearn a lot of what I had learned as a journalist. The biggest limitation in newspaper writing is its lack of a distinctive voice; use of the first person is frowned upon, perhaps because it detracts from the ideal of the neutral observer. When a journalist occasionally runs into himself in a story, the result is comically awkward: The subject of an article spoke to “a reporter” or “a foreign visitor” or perhaps “a correspondent for this newspaper”—any contortion to avoid the forbidden “I.” A journalist learns to write as if she does not exist.

Figuring out how to write about myself was the biggest challenge of the book. Along with following the lives of several young migrant women, my book also traces my own family’s migrations within China and to the West. That was my plan from the start, but carrying it out was painful. “You seem almost a frozen observer,” commented a friend after reading a first draft. “You are the connection between the stories of the girls and the family stories,” my editor reminded me. “Without you, the two parts don’t hold together!” It took two substantial revisions to write myself into my own book.

In place of the personal voice, journalism substitutes the voice of absolute authority. This posture is not only dangerous—it’s easy to be wrong—but it infects one’s writing style in subtle ways. Ideas are rendered in short, clipped statements of truth. Sentences follow an identical and repetitive structure, the better to hammer home a point. Paragraphs are frequently truncated—this is writing as PowerPoint presentation, one fact per paragraph, leading the reader to the inevitable conclusion.

The journalistic voice strangles the imagination. The editor’s eternal question—How do you know this?—leaves almost no room to bring a person or a place to life. In my book, this is how I describe Lu Qingmin, the sixteen-year-old migrant worker:

She was short and sturdily built, with curly hair and keen dark eyes that didn’t miss a thing. Like many young people from the Chinese countryside, she looked even younger than she was. She could have been fifteen, or fourteen, or even twelve—a tomboy in cargo pants and running shoes, waiting impatiently to grow up. She had a child’s face. It was round and open to the world, with the look of patient expectation that children’s faces sometimes wear.

In the Wall Street Journal story, I nailed her in one sentence: Min has a round face, curly hair and big eyes. I didn’t realize at the time the inadequacy of that description, because I was too busy fighting other battles against the newspaper’s rules of style. I didn’t want to refer to the teenage Min as “Ms. Lu,” which seemed jarringly formal; I argued against having to attribute every detail to a source, as is journalistic convention. I won those battles, but there were others I lost, and still others I didn’t even fight. As I said, the voice of the imaginary editor is always in my head.

The primary flaw of journalism is impatience. Ever mindful of the competition, editors always want the story sooner, and reporters internalize this urgency in their tendency to move in and out of places quickly. But this approach not only misses the nuances, it risks missing the story altogether. When I first met Min in February 2004, she had just finished a year at an electronics factory marked by bad conditions, low pay, and thirteen-hour workdays. Over three years, she jumped jobs six times, working her way up from the assembly line to a clerical position to human resources and finally a factory’s powerful purchasing department. At one point, she considered throwing it all away to follow her boyfriend to Beijing where he would work as a security guard; another time, she was robbed of her mobile phone and nine hundred yuan in cash as she slept in a cheap hostel. If a reporter had met her at any of those points, he would have come away with a grim story. Because I was able to follow Min for three years, I could see that migration, for all its ups and downs, had brought her opportunity and success.

The discoveries that come from patient observation are not necessarily things that your subjects will share with you. The lives of most Chinese have changed beyond recognition in the past two decades, yet it is rare to hear someone speak thoughtfully about this transformation. The instinct against introspection runs deep, and people are so caught up in the present that they often lack perspective. None of the factory girls I knew in Dongguan ever talked about what they had achieved since coming out from home; maybe they worried they would lose momentum if they looked backward. After my first article about Min was published in the Journal, I gave her a translated copy. She read the piece like a revelation—almost as if it were the story of someone else. Seeing the self I used to be, she wrote me in an e-mail afterward, I realize that I have really changed.

*

I don’t regret my years as a journalist. I learned how to get information, how to keep asking questions until I understood something, how to cobble together bits and pieces from multiple sources if there was no one Deep Throat—as there almost never is. Especially when reporting in a place as rapidly changing and statistically blurry as China, it is important to have faith that the truth can be found. For example, in my book I wanted to draw attention to the heavily female migrant population of Dongguan, but the city government did not have an official statistic; its figure, which counted only locally registered residents, was useless to me. So I did what I had been taught at the Journal: I began asking everyone I met what they thought the figure was. Eventually I combined the findings of a talent market executive, city officials, factory bosses, and a local newspaper survey to estimate that the city’s population was 70 percent female. The shortcomings and cautiousness of others should not keep you from making conclusions—this is one lesson you learn as a journalist.

Early in my newspaper career, I argued with a copyeditor who had changed a sentence in my story to something less graceful. “We’re not trying to be Emily Dickinson here,” he snapped—a remark whose sting lingered for years. I wish I had known then how many others had fought this fight before me. The young Mark Twain was regarded by his editors at the San Francisco Call as “incurably literary,” and his idiosyncratic writing style eventually got him fired. Ernest Hemingway, correspondent for the Toronto Star, complained, “this goddam newspaper stuff is gradually ruining me.” Both men became not only great novelists but also pioneers of literary nonfiction, using subjective impressions and the techniques of fiction to bring true experiences to life. As a longtime journalist, I feel some consolation to see the connections between the reporters they were and the writers they became.

Leslie T. Chang worked in China for a decade as a correspondent for the Wall Street Journal. Her book, Factory Girls, will be published in October by Spiegel & Grau, an imprint of the Doubleday Publishing Group.

14 comments:

Megha said...

Leslie, thanks for writing this. I've just graduated from J-school in the U.S. and am about to start my reporting career in China, so your insights were really valuable to me. I'll be looking forward to reading your book.

Anonymous said...

I enjoyed reading your article in National Geographic magazine's China issue. Thanks for telling the story of the Chinese people. Keep up with the good work!

unstrung said...

This post makes total sense to me. I am also a former journalist, making the transition into the literary world. Once you've stepped away from journalism, especially news reporting, and seen its limits, you can never go back, try as hard as you might. I know exactly what you mean, and was struck as I read The Paris Reviews, by what Hemingway and others said about the limits of journalism. Well done for getting your book finished. You are faster than I. I am still working on mine. It is such a pleasure, though, to create, not regurgitate within the restrictive false-making measures of news.
unstrunglarapawson.wordpress.com

leggo said...

Leslie,
Not to get off track, but this is the only place I could find I(didn't look too hard) to contact you. I just read a book review you did on Outliers. That review was one of the best I've read - ever. Damn, you're a good writer.

-John
Las Vegas

tiff said...

Leslie,

I have enjoyed your most recent book so much that I checked out a copy of your first(?) book, and ended up buying a copy from Amazon for that book as well.
It's wonderful to see that someone is writing about China with insight as well as emotion. I'm grateful that someone can summarize my own jumboed feelings towards China, both the culture and the people, with eloquence and clarity.
As someone from Southern Cal (specifically, the one you referred to as the "Chinese suburb"), I'm somewhat mystified that you don't have a book signing tour in our area. It's true that on the whole, we are a cloister bunch, self-statisied in our little home away from home-country kind of way. But I think there are enough 2nd/3rd generation who are interested in the topics you had written about to warrant a stop here.
If that's not enough, you do remember we have the most diversified, truly authentic, and just as important, very cheap Chinese food right.

sinolicious said...

Wow Leslie,

From reading "Factory Girls" I never would have thought you had trouble as a journalist or doubted your writing abilities.

I absolutely love-love- loved reading the book, and its refreshing to hear accounts your of China from the peoples perspective.

Initially I was put off by the introduction, like you said its not something the reader expects in a first page. But the book went on to be an amazing window into the lives of the female migrant workers in China. I wouldn't like it any other way.

Keep the good stuff rolling Leslie. You have an amazing voice and perspective.

-stephen
@sinolicious.wordpress.com

mb in Port Angeles said...

I'm reading _Factory Girls_ right now, getting near the end and very sorry to have to leave that world.

Because you have persuaded me how fast and how constantly everything changes in their lives, I've been fretting about the gap in time between when you left Dongguan and the present. By now Min and Chunming and the others must surely have entirely different lives several times over -- and the economic stress going on at the moment must have changed it all again.

As a reporter you might still have been in China, telling the story. But as an author of books, are you moved on to another project, and disconnected from the women whose lives you shared?

It's a terrific book, and I've been telling everyone about it. Thanks for have done this project.

oracle said...

Hi Leslie, I just finish your book, and it's an interesting perspective from the factory girl's point of view on all that is happening in China today. However, I thought there was too much emphasis on your grandfather and his historical importance, and I would have liked to see more on the limited opportunities of rural girls after the Chinese Civil War and on through the turbulant Cultural Revolution. For example, I understand there were many American Chinese men during this time who went back to China and elsewhere to pick wives during this time. The pool of these women are basically from the same pool for factory girls today. I thought a section on the historical interest, longings, and dreams of these women would have been fascinating.

Lety Padilla said...

Dear Leslie, I also have just finished reading Factory Girls after first learning about it in a NYT book review. Thank you for taking on this project. Through your writing you are taking the American reading public across galaxies of distance in their understanding of modern china.

Like another commenter above, I also had difficulty finding information about you on the web. Do you have a website anywhere? I was looking for a page that might link to other things you have written - articles, essays, whatever, but I couldn't find it.

It seems to me you are missing a big opportunity not having such a page. I hope to keep following your work in the future. Thanks again.

Promotional Cards said...

I am really sad when i write your post,it is our world where for for accomplishing of our needs we become machine :( .

Anonymous said...

Dear Leslie, like others here, I thank you for The Factory Girls. Accurate observation. Sharp analysis. Warm and patient friendship, but still objective interpretation. – Having three times visited my son living in Beijing, with this book I more clearly understood what I saw and heard in that culture. Furthermore, with Leslie’s description I could fill the gap between what was visible and what was hidden behind the cultural veil. Regards from a Finnish reader

Anonymous said...

Leslie, your book was amazing. I absolutely enjoyed every sentence. I read the book in about 4 hours, I could not put it down.
You did an awesome job.

Anonymous said...

Leslie,
I just finished reading your book and I found it thoroughly fascinating. I adopted my daughter from North China in 2005 and am constantly looking for good information about the reality of life in China and this information is not that easy to find. Thank you for giving us a glimpse into the lives that could have easily been my daughter's. Please keep writing. I enjoy reading both yours and your husband's work.

jack said...

Leslie,

Thank you for your work on "Factory Girls." I read the book this week and feel like gained a valuable perspective on the lives of millions of migrant workers in China that would have otherwise taken me years to learn.

My family is preparing to move to northern China to live and work in the city of Hohhot, Inner Mongolia this summer.

I suppose this is our chuqu.